Complementary Antibacterial Effects of Bacteriocins and Organic Acids as Revealed by Comparative Analysis of Carnobacterium spp. from Meat.

Carnobacterium maltaromaticum and Carnobacterium divergens are often predominant in the microbiota of vacuum-packaged (VP) meats after prolonged storage at chiller temperatures, and more so in recent studies. We investigated the antibacterial activities of C. maltaromaticum and C. divergens (n = 31) from VP meats by phenotypic characterization and genomic analysis. Five strains showed antibacterial activities against Gram-positive bacteria in a spot-lawn assay, with C. maltaromaticum strains having an intergeneric and C. divergens strains an intrageneric inhibition spectrum. This inhibitory activity is correlated with the production of predicted bacteriocins, including carnobacteriocin B2 and carnolysin for C. maltaromaticum and divergicin A for C. divergens The supernatants of both species cultured in meat juice medium under anaerobic conditions retarded the growth of most Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria in broth assay in a strain-dependent manner. C. maltaromaticum and C. divergens produced formate and acetate but not lactate under VP meat-relevant conditions. The relative inhibitory activity by Carnobacterium strains was significantly correlated (P < 0.05) to the production of both acids. Genomic analysis revealed the presence of genes required for respiration in both species. In addition, two clusters of C. divergens have an average nucleotide identity below the cutoff value for species delineation and thus should be considered to be two subspecies. In conclusion, both bacteriocins and organic acids are factors contributing significantly to the antibacterial activity of C. maltaromaticum and C. divergens under VP meat-relevant conditions. A few Carnobacterium strains can be explored as protective cultures to extend the shelf life and improve the safety of VP meats.IMPORTANCE The results of this study demonstrated that both bacteriocins and organic acids are important factors contributing to the antibacterial activities of Carnobacterium from vacuum-packaged (VP) meats. This study demonstrated that formate and acetate are the key organic acids produced by Carnobacterium and demonstrated their association with the inhibitory activity of carnobacteria under VP meat-relevant storage conditions. The role of lactate, on the other hand, may not be as important as previously believed in the antimicrobial activities of Carnobacterium spp. on chilled VP meats. These findings advance our understanding of the physiology of Carnobacterium spp. to better explore their biopreservative properties for chilled VP meats.

Growth of Carnobacterium spp. isolated from chilled vacuum-packaged meat under relevant acidic conditions.

Carnobacterium spp. are frequently isolated from vacuum-packaged (VP) meat. Specific strains of Carnobacterium and their growth characteristics may be associated with the storage life of such products. This study investigated the growth of 44 Carnobacterium isolates obtained from VP meat cuts produced at three Canadian abattoirs (A, B and C) under the following conditions: pH 5.4, 6.2 and 7.4; lactic acid at 60 and 90 mM; acetic acid at 33.6 mM. Whole genome sequencing was performed for all 44 isolates and a core genome phylogenetic tree was created to identify strain variability among isolates from different abattoirs. The isolates were clustered into 11 groups. All isolates from abattoirs B and C were identified as C. divergens, while the isolates from abattoir A included both C. maltaromaticum and C. divergens at equal proportions. C. divergens isolates from abattoir A belonged to two phylogenetic groups and none of them was found in the phylogenetic groups containing isolates from abattoirs B or C. Whole genome sequencing revealed that identical strains were isolated from different samples obtained at the same abattoir. The mean growth rate and maximum population density of the C. maltaromaticum isolates were lower than those of the C. divergens isolates. C. divergens isolates from abattoir A had higher growth rates and maximum population density than those from abattoirs B and C. In conclusion, growth characteristic and whole genome analysis both demonstrated strain variability of Carnobacterium among abattoirs, which could be a result of the difference in the antimicrobial interventions used for carcasses at different abattoirs, and may be associated with different storage lives of VP meats produced from different abattoirs.

Microbial deterioration of vacuum-packaged chilled beef cuts and techniques for microbiota detection and characterization: a review

Gas production from microbial deterioration in vacuum-packs of chilled meat leads to pack distension, which is commonly referred as blown pack. This phenomenon is attributed to some psychrophilic and psychrotrophic Clostridium species, as well as Enterobacteria. The ability of these microorganisms to grow at refrigeration temperatures makes the control by the meat industry a challenge. This type of deterioration has been reported in many countries including some plants in the Midwestern and Southeastern regions of Brazil. In addition to causing economic losses, spoilage negatively impacts the commercial product brand, thereby impairing the meat industry. In the case of strict anaerobes species they are difficult to grow and isolate using culture methods in conventional microbiology laboratories. Furthermore, conventional culture methods are sometimes not capable of distinguishing species or genera. DNA-based molecular methods are alternative strategies for detecting viable and non-cultivable microorganisms and strict anaerobic microorganisms that are difficult to cultivate. Here, we review the microorganisms and mechanisms involved in the deterioration of vacuum-packaged chilled meat and address the use of molecular methods for detecting specific strict anaerobic microorganisms and microbial communities in meat samples.

Microbial deterioration of vacuum-packaged chilled beef cuts and techniques for microbiota detection and characterization: a review.

Gas production from microbial deterioration in vacuum-packs of chilled meat leads to pack distension, which is commonly referred as blown pack. This phenomenon is attributed to some psychrophilic and psychrotrophic Clostridium species, as well as Enterobacteria. The ability of these microorganisms to grow at refrigeration temperatures makes the control by the meat industry a challenge. This type of deterioration has been reported in many countries including some plants in the Midwestern and Southeastern regions of Brazil. In addition to causing economic losses, spoilage negatively impacts the commercial product brand, thereby impairing the meat industry. In the case of strict anaerobes species they are difficult to grow and isolate using culture methods in conventional microbiology laboratories. Furthermore, conventional culture methods are sometimes not capable of distinguishing species or genera. DNA-based molecular methods are alternative strategies for detecting viable and non-cultivable microorganisms and strict anaerobic microorganisms that are difficult to cultivate. Here, we review the microorganisms and mechanisms involved in the deterioration of vacuum-packaged chilled meat and address the use of molecular methods for detecting specific strict anaerobic microorganisms and microbial communities in meat samples.